Sunday, July 05, 2009

Shisha Ban? or Humdrum Ramblings?

I was casually listening to one of the English radio stations yesterday as I drove to grab an argileh (shisha) at the B café. There was a female presenter talking about health and stuff, and somehow the subject of smoking was brought up. Her guest was a guy who was talking about a Ministry of Health initiative (but I doubt he works for them), he said that there’s a massive campaign for smoke cessation in the gulf that included posters with photos that will elicit awareness in the prefrontal cortex of a smoker. He also said that invitations  were sent out to graphic designers with a brief to come up with the most horrific and graphic scenes that will be printed on cigarette packs all across the gulf. The presenter then asked him about shisha, and I’d have plugged my ears if I weren’t clutching the wheels with both hands. He went on how horrible shisha is for health and how a head/stone (rass or hagar, depends where you come from) is equivalent to 20-40 cigarettes. He said that the ministry is adamant on banning hooka altogether in the future, especially that its smokers aren’t aware of the perils that await them. The presenter agreed with him that the situation is frightening. You can tell where the rest of the conversation was going……

Yes, the situation is frightening; it’s also frightening with all those fast-food joints that are meant to sustain the calorie intake of your fat ass. It’s also frightening to go to the beach in the searing sun and get a sunstroke. It’s also frightening when the UAE is experiencing an endemic in diabetes and other similar illnesses induced by high cholesterol and sedentary life style. You want frightening? Go and watch the patrons of bars and clubs getting out at 3 AM Saturday morning with their wobbling heads and bleary eyes. Think of the platoons of drunk drivers descending upon the city at the aforesaid hour. Alcoholism, frightening not? Have you been to any restaurant in Mina Bazar area? Have you seen how the food is being prepared? And while you’re in Bur Dubai, would you please make a list of all possible ways of contracting STDs?

It’s hypocritical to ask for the shisha to be banned when you’re not a smoker. Unlike cigarette smoke, this is a practice restricted to certain areas approved and inspected by the municipality. Even the air we breath inside the joints isn’t shared with the general population. It’s impossible to be a second hand shisha smoker unless you make the conscious decision of getting in that air-tight space. So what do you want to ban shisha for? You’re worried about young adults getting addicted, maybe you could demand a letter with a guardian consent, or you could raise the minimum age to 25? How about you put up posters of charred lungs and rotten airways in all the shisha joints? That should be enough deterrence, should it not? I may as will help with the graphic design, heck, after seeing photos from Abu Ghuraib and Gaza, nothing really moves a human being any more. Or if we wanna be realistic, let’s ban fast food and cola and alcohol and jugging on dusty days. Because in the socialist country we live in, my public-provided health insurance is paid by your tax money. And that entitles you to interfere.  Because, you know, grown-up people aren’t ever capable of making conscious and responsible decisions. I’m awaiting your graphic designs to make up my mind.

Heck, I should probably quit smoking, I could just inhale the dust instead.




Dust storm , Shisha smoke , Clean air on Shiekh Zayed road , 05/7/09.

16 comments:

Dave said...

DJ I think you make a very good point that no one is effected by second-hand shisha smoke unless they make a conscious decision to be around it.

It should not be treated in the same manner as cigarette smoking. If someone wants to smoke it in the environment where it is permitted than why shouldn't they? I don't know anyone that gets up in the morning, has a good cough and fires up the shisha....

samuraisam said...

A shisha is not equivalent to 20-40 cigarettes, that is and has always been a crock of shit research.

Most of the risks shown in just about the only research paper on the subject say that the instant coal is was creates many of the hazards they include in their conclusion and we all know anyone who's worth their weight doesn't smoke that shit and uses real iranian lemon wood coals (which aren't instant).

Lujayn said...

I agree, DJ. Not a smoker but I respect smokers' choices (after all, smoking areas are largely regulated), in as much as I would expect everyone to respect my choice to have an icecream despite my unfit shape. We're adults, we know what we're getting into when we inhale/ingest whatever our vice of choice is. May you long get to enjoy your shisha, DJ, even if you do end up with black lungs and the sort :))

hemlock said...
This comment has been removed by the author.
hemlock said...

my friend and i were having sheesha in abu dhabi when a group of 5-6 arabs came in, with a child less than 5 months old (she wasnt even sitting up).
as her family smoked their various flavours, she was passed from person to person for the entire time they were there.

i personally wanted to get up and punch the mother, but really, at the end of the day, it's none of my business, even if it is child abuse. i cant tell someone how to live their life, no matter how effed up they are.

if the government trusts us to run its institutions, it should trust us to live our lives as we see fit.

and stupid people shouldnt be on the radio.

Yazan said...

I am not sure what regulations there are when it comes to Shisha smoking in Dubai, but I know for sure that back home we need strict regulations and NOW.

I smoke (cigarettes, not shisha), and I would be the first one in line to support a 20-years smoking age, and smoking ban in public areas. It's just sensible and logical.

Dubai Jazz said...

Dave,

You're right. Although I'm not trying to say that shisha smokers are more health-aware than cigarette smokers, we're all in the same boat. But second-hand shisha smoke has always been easier to contain.

Dubai Jazz said...

Sam,
I heard about the research, and thanks for setting the record straight. And we also know how parameters and conditions could be manipulated to drive results toward a certain direction in any experiment. I, for instance, hate cigarettes like hell. I get instance dizziness, sore throat and the closest thing to nicotine poison the moment I smoke a single cigarette, while shisha on the other hand doesn’t affect me that much.

And you’re right about the Iranian lemon charcoal. I even know the guy who supply it!

Dubai Jazz said...

Lujayn,
Thank you for supporting me and my choice. Even though I know how much you despise smoking in general :)

Well, I do not intend to defend the bad habbit, my only intention is to defend my right to my 'poison' as long as others have theirs.

Dubai Jazz said...

Hemlock,

Why the racial profiling? :P

I’ve seem babies of all ages in the cafes….. and of several nationalities… it’s an abhorrent thing to do to a child. I know some Lebanese families who make their toddlers (as young as 3 years old) sip Arak with the kabab at Friday lunches (although never seen it here in Dubai), and yes, I’d put that down there with child abuse. Funny thing is, most of these families have nannies and maids trailing behind. They could just keep the poor baby at home or by the non-smoking area…

Dubai Jazz said...

Yazan,
The situation in Syria is totally different. As I remember, there is no enforcement of regulations whatsoever on argileh or cigarette smoke. Everybody smokes everywhere in Syria, there’s hardly any none-smoking area anywhere. Not even public transport or government buildings are spared.

In Dubai it’s another story. There’s zero tolerance policy for smoking in public places. And as Lujayn said, the few smoking zones are heavily regulated, technically and legally. And that is all acceptable and commended, but what’s not acceptable is to confiscate my right to smoke by banning the serving of argelih to the public altogether.

samuraisam said...

dubai jazz: same thing for me! and many of these studies use people who smoke cigarettes as well as shisha smokers!
I've been smoking shisha regularly (probably once every 10 days or so on average) for the past 5-6 years and have never had any problems from it, I spent a few long days working on a project at a friends house where he and another friend were smoking cigarettes non-stop and I got a very screwed up throat just from the second hand smoke!

The other important factor is that shisha is not addictive (depending on the tobacco that you choose, I choose tobacco which contains only 0.05% nicotine and 0% tar, I also choose really good coal, and I also choose good aluminum foil etc); I haven't had a shisha for the past week and I don't feel any cravings whatsoever. If I want to have a shisha it's because I feel like relaxing and meeting some friends for a while, not because I'm addicted.

hemlock: by law people under the age of 20 aren't allowed inside a Shisha cafe in Dubai even if they don't smoke. This is a good law. It just needs better enforcement.

Allie said...

A post after my own heart. Anti-smoking nonsense drives me insane (whether it's shisha or cigarettes).

the real nick said...

Good on you Jazza. Spoken like a true Syrian.

KJ said...

I can't help but snort laughing. What do THEY smoke when they come up with these regulations anyway?

Dubai needs to worry about more important things, like the ones you mentioned. Plus everyone is a second hand smoker thanks to the surplus of smog and dust storms.

Genevieve (The Sacred Narghile) said...

Is Medical Concern about Hookah Environmental Tobacco Smoke Hazards Warranted ?

http://www.bentham-open.org/pages/content.php?TOGMJ/2009/00000003/00000001/31TOGMJ.SGM

In-depth study (with nice pics):

Hookah (Shisha, Narghile) Smoking and Environmental Tobacco Smoke (ETS). A Critical Review of the Relevant Literature and the Public Health Consequences


http://www.pubmedcentral.nih.gov/articlerender.fcgi?artid=2672364